The Brass Key Guesthouse Review: Provincetown's Most Luxurious Gay Hotel? (2026)
Provincetown, Massachusetts is arguably the most famous gay beach town in America. Located at the tip of Cape Cod, this charming seaside town combines beautiful beaches, legendary nightlife, incredible restaurants, and one of the most welcoming gay communities you'll find anywhere.
And if you're looking for the ultimate place to stay in Provincetown, few properties are as well known—or as beloved—as The Brass Key Guesthouse.
During our recent stay in Provincetown, we checked into The Brass Key to see if it truly lives up to its reputation as the premier gay hotel in town. From its award-winning heated pool and massive hot tub to its unbeatable location near Commercial Street and Boy Beach, here's everything you need to know before booking your stay.
And if you're looking for the ultimate place to stay in Provincetown, few properties are as well known—or as beloved—as The Brass Key Guesthouse.
During our recent stay in Provincetown, we checked into The Brass Key to see if it truly lives up to its reputation as the premier gay hotel in town. From its award-winning heated pool and massive hot tub to its unbeatable location near Commercial Street and Boy Beach, here's everything you need to know before booking your stay.
🌟 Pro tip – Planning a trip to Provincetown? Don’t miss our Gay Travel Guide to Provincetown, where we cover the best hotels, things to do, restaurants, beaches, and LGBTQ+ nightlife in town.
Why Stay at The Brass Key Guesthouse?
Named one of the top small hotels in the United States by Condé Nast Traveler, The Brass Key Guesthouse has become a Provincetown institution.
This adults-oriented LGBTQ+ property offers:
- 43 guest rooms and suites
- Heated infinity pool
- Large outdoor hot tub
- Complimentary breakfast
- Evening wine and cheese reception
- Shipwreck Lounge cocktail bar
- Complimentary bicycles
- Free parking
- Prime location near Provincetown nightlife
What makes The Brass Key special isn't just the amenities—it's the atmosphere. The property feels welcoming, social, upscale, and uniquely Provincetown.
Whether you're visiting for Pride, Bear Week, Carnival, or simply a summer getaway, The Brass Key offers one of the best home bases in town.
Location
One of the biggest advantages of staying at The Brass Key is its location.
Situated on historic Bradford Street, you're within walking distance of nearly everything Provincetown has to offer.
Some nearby highlights include:
- Tea Dance at Boatslip
- A-House Nightclub
- Commercial Street shopping and restaurants
- MacMillan Pier
- Pilgrim Monument
- Provincetown Harbor
- Boy Beach Bike Racks
We especially loved being able to borrow complimentary bikes and ride to Boy Beach in about ten minutes.
Once you arrive in Provincetown, you can easily leave the car behind and explore on foot or by bike.
Amenities
From the street, The Brass Key looks like a charming New England guesthouse.
Once you step inside, however, you'll discover a surprisingly expansive gated compound filled with gardens, courtyards, and multiple historic buildings.
Heated Infinity Pool
The centerpiece of the property is the heated infinity pool.
We visited early one morning after a quick rain shower and had the entire pool area to ourselves. With the sun reflecting off the water and the gardens surrounding the property, it felt incredibly peaceful.
Large Outdoor Hot Tub
Adjacent to the pool is one of the largest hot tubs we've found at a gay resort.
It's especially popular in the evenings when guests gather to socialize before heading out to Provincetown's bars and clubs.
Complimentary Bikes
One of our favorite perks is the complimentary bicycle program.
Not only does it make exploring Provincetown easy, but it's also the perfect way to reach Boy Beach without dealing with parking or long walks.
Hospitality
The staff deserves special recognition.
Everyone we encountered—from the front desk team to breakfast attendants—genuinely seemed invested in making our stay exceptional.
Need restaurant recommendations? Beach tips? Nightlife suggestions?
They've got you covered.
Accomodations
For our stay, we booked Room 157, a Deluxe King Room located in the Queen Anne House.
The room immediately impressed us.
Large windows on three sides flood the space with natural light while offering views of the pool area below.
Room Highlights
- King-size four-poster bed
- Sitting area for two
- Mini-fridge
- Keurig coffee maker
- Large dresser
- Closet with robes and safe
- Iron and ironing board
- Strong Wi-Fi
- Flat-screen TV
- Beach towels
- Rain umbrellas
The nautical-inspired design feels perfectly suited to Provincetown while remaining elegant and comfortable.
Bathroom
The bathroom was another standout.
Bright, modern, and spacious, it featured one of the best showers we've experienced during our travels through New England.
It's the type of room you genuinely look forward to returning to after a day at the beach.
Food & Drink
The Brass Key does an excellent job keeping guests fed, caffeinated, and hydrated throughout the day.
Daily Breakfast
Served in Roomer's Cafe, breakfast is included with every stay.
During our visit, offerings included:
- Fresh fruit
- Cranberry muffins
- Pastries
- Coffee
- Juice
- Hot breakfast selections
Everything was fresh, well-presented, and exactly what we wanted before heading out to explore Provincetown.
Complimentary Coffee
Coffee lovers will appreciate the complimentary gourmet coffee available throughout the day.
As frequent coffee drinkers ourselves, we definitely took advantage of this perk.
Wine & Cheese Happy Hour
Each evening from 5:00 PM to 6:00 PM, guests are invited to enjoy:
- Wine
- Cheese
- Crudités
It's a fantastic opportunity to meet fellow travelers before heading out for the night.
Shipwreck Lounge
Located onsite, Shipwreck Lounge has become known as Provincetown's living room.
The atmosphere is relaxed and social, making it one of our favorite places to enjoy a cocktail before dinner or nightlife.
The bartenders are friendly, the drinks are excellent, and the crowd is always welcoming.
How to Get to Provincetown
Most travelers arrive via Boston.
Fly into Boston Logan Airport (BOS)
From Boston, you have several options:
- Drive
- Bus
- Cape Air flight
- High-speed ferry
Our Favorite Option: Ferry
Our preferred choice is the Bay State Cruise Company ferry departing from Boston's Seaport District.
Travel time is approximately 1 hour and 40 minutes.
The ferry drops passengers directly at MacMillan Pier in the center of Provincetown.
As an added bonus, you'll pass Boy Beach and get fantastic views of Provincetown Harbor during the journey.
There's even a convenient water taxi shuttle service available from Provincetown back to Logan Airport on departure day.
Is The Brass Key Worth It?
Absolutely.
After our stay, it's easy to understand why The Brass Key has developed such a loyal following.
Between:
- Prime location
- Heated pool
- Huge hot tub
- Complimentary breakfast
- Wine & cheese reception
- Beautiful accommodations
- Exceptional staff
...it delivers everything most travelers are looking for in a Provincetown getaway.
While Provincetown certainly isn't the cheapest destination in the United States, The Brass Key provides an experience that feels worthy of the splurge.
If you're searching for the most luxurious gay hotel in Provincetown, this is the one we'd book again without hesitation.
Frequently Asked Questions & Travel Tips
Is The Brass Key Guesthouse adults only?
Yes. The Brass Key is an adults-oriented property and one of Provincetown's most popular LGBTQ+ accommodations.
Does The Brass Key have a pool?
Yes. The property features an award-winning heated infinity pool and one of the largest outdoor hot tubs in Provincetown.
Is The Brass Key clothing optional?
No. The pool and hot tub areas are not clothing optional.
Is breakfast included?
Yes. A complimentary daily breakfast is included with your stay, along with coffee throughout the day and an evening wine and cheese reception.
Can you bike to Boy Beach from The Brass Key?
Yes. Complimentary bicycles are available for guests, and the Boy Beach Bike Racks are approximately ten minutes away.
Is The Brass Key close to Provincetown nightlife?
Absolutely. You're within walking distance of Tea Dance at Boatslip, A-House, Shipwreck Lounge (onsite), Commercial Street, and many of Provincetown's most popular bars and restaurants.
Ready To Book?
If you're planning a trip to Provincetown and want the most luxurious gay guesthouse in town, The Brass Key Guesthouse should be at the top of your list.
With beautiful accommodations, outstanding amenities, exceptional service, and one of the best locations in Provincetown, it's easy to see why guests return year after year.
Found this post useful? The easiest way to support Two Gay Expats is to subscribe (free!) to our YouTube channel and tell your friends and family about us to help us grow (also free)! And if you find our content helpful and/or entertaining, please consider joining our Channel Membership on YouTube to directly support our videos or Patreon to gain access to exclusive behind-the-scenes content.
Did we get something wrong? Has a business we highlighted closed or perhaps something new and fabulous opened? Are you interested in working with us? In all cases, we'd love to hear from you! Email us at hello@twogayexpats.com.
